Bring A Large Pot Of Salted Water To A Boil. Cook The Elbow Macaroni Until Just Past Al Dente According To Package Instructions.
Drain And Rinse Under Cold Water Until Completely Cool. Let The Pasta Drain Well So The Salad Doesn’t Become Watery.
While The Pasta Cools, Chop The Eggs, Celery, Onion, And Pickles.
In A Large Bowl, Whisk Together The Mayonnaise, Mustard, Vinegar, Sugar, Salt, Pepper, And Paprika Until Smooth.
Add The Cooled Pasta, Eggs, Celery, Onion, Pickles, And Carrot To The Bowl. Stir Until Everything Is Evenly Coated.
Chill Before Serving
Cover And Refrigerate For At Least 1 Hour Before Serving For The Best Flavor.
Stir Again Before Serving And Add A Spoonful Of Mayo If Needed To Freshen It Up.